Medicare Traditional Default and Advantage Accountability Act
Makes original Medicare the default for everyone. Requires Medicare Advantage plans to cover what original Medicare covers and bars inflated diagnosis billing.
Original Medicare is the default for everyone who becomes eligible. No one may be enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan without active, written consent.
Medicare Advantage plans must cover every service that original Medicare covers, and may not deny care a doctor orders as medically necessary without a published review.
Risk scores paid to Medicare Advantage plans must rest on audited diagnoses. Plans that were overpaid for unsupported diagnoses repay the full amount with interest.
Payments to Medicare Advantage plans may not exceed the cost of original Medicare for the same enrollee, and no extra bonus payments are allowed.
Medicare benefits may not be cut, and the Medicare trust fund may not be used to pay for tax breaks.
Enforcement and penalties
Enforced by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the HHS Inspector General, and the Department of Justice False Claims Act unit.
Criminal: a plan or provider that knowingly submits false diagnoses faces up to 10 years in prison.
Civil: treble damages under the False Claims Act, plus fines of up to $100,000 per false claim, indexed to inflation.
Remedies: repayment with interest, exclusion from Medicare for up to 10 years, and qui tam suits by whistleblowers who share in the recovery.
Why
Project 2025 supports steering people toward Medicare Advantage private plans and cutting Medicare spending. Federal audits have raised concerns about inflated diagnosis coding in these plans, which costs taxpayers money. This law makes original Medicare the default and requires every dollar paid to a private plan to be earned.
Bills already in Congress
False Claims ActEnacted 1863 (12 Stat. 696); codified at 31 U.S.C. 3729-3733Lets the government and whistleblowers recover fraud against federal programs. This item applies it directly to Medicare Advantage risk scores and sets default-enrollment rules.
Links go to the bill or law on Congress.gov or GovInfo, or to a Congress.gov search by its name.
Start a petition
A petition shows how many people want this. Copy the text, start a petition, paste it in, and share the petition link.
I am your constituent, and I vote. Please support a law that keeps original Medicare as the default and stops inflated billing by Medicare Advantage plans.
Medicare Traditional Default and Advantage Accountability Act. Makes original Medicare the default for everyone. Requires Medicare Advantage plans to cover what original Medicare covers and bars inflated diagnosis billing.
The law I am asking for would do the following:
Original Medicare is the default for everyone who becomes eligible. No one may be enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan without active, written consent.
Medicare Advantage plans must cover every service that original Medicare covers, and may not deny care a doctor orders as medically necessary without a published review.
Risk scores paid to Medicare Advantage plans must rest on audited diagnoses. Plans that were overpaid for unsupported diagnoses repay the full amount with interest.
Payments to Medicare Advantage plans may not exceed the cost of original Medicare for the same enrollee, and no extra bonus payments are allowed.
Medicare benefits may not be cut, and the Medicare trust fund may not be used to pay for tax breaks.
It must have teeth:
Enforced by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the HHS Inspector General, and the Department of Justice False Claims Act unit.
Criminal: a plan or provider that knowingly submits false diagnoses faces up to 10 years in prison.
Civil: treble damages under the False Claims Act, plus fines of up to $100,000 per false claim, indexed to inflation.
Remedies: repayment with interest, exclusion from Medicare for up to 10 years, and qui tam suits by whistleblowers who share in the recovery.
Please tell me in writing whether you will introduce, cosponsor or vote for this, and if not, why not.