No Supreme Court Appointments in a Lame-Duck Presidency
No president may nominate a Supreme Court justice during a lame-duck period. The lame-duck period runs from the day of the presidential election until the next president takes the oath of office.
The lame-duck period starts on election day and ends when the next president takes the oath of office.
No nomination for a Supreme Court seat may be sent to the Senate during the lame-duck period.
A nomination sent during the lame-duck period is void on the day it is sent.
The seat stays open until the next president makes a nomination after taking office.
Enforcement and penalties
Enforced by the Senate, which may not hold a confirmation vote, and by federal courts, which may void an improper nomination.
Criminal: an official who knowingly sends, signs or certifies an improper nomination faces up to 5 years in prison.
Civil: forfeiture of any pay or benefit tied to the nomination, and a fine of up to 1 year of the official's pay.
Remedies: a private right of action that lets any citizen sue to void the nomination, and impeachment for any official who knowingly violates the rule.
Why
A president who has already lost the vote can still fill a seat on the highest court for decades. The seat should be filled by the president the voters chose in the next election.
Bills already in Congress
No bill in Congress does this yet. The text on this page is the proposal.
Start a petition
A petition shows how many people want this. Copy the text, start a petition, paste it in, and share the petition link.
I am your constituent, and I vote. Please support a constitutional amendment that bars Supreme Court nominations during a lame-duck presidency.
No Supreme Court Appointments in a Lame-Duck Presidency. No president may nominate a Supreme Court justice during a lame-duck period. The lame-duck period runs from the day of the presidential election until the next president takes the oath of office.
The law I am asking for would do the following:
The lame-duck period starts on election day and ends when the next president takes the oath of office.
No nomination for a Supreme Court seat may be sent to the Senate during the lame-duck period.
A nomination sent during the lame-duck period is void on the day it is sent.
The seat stays open until the next president makes a nomination after taking office.
It must have teeth:
Enforced by the Senate, which may not hold a confirmation vote, and by federal courts, which may void an improper nomination.
Criminal: an official who knowingly sends, signs or certifies an improper nomination faces up to 5 years in prison.
Civil: forfeiture of any pay or benefit tied to the nomination, and a fine of up to 1 year of the official's pay.
Remedies: a private right of action that lets any citizen sue to void the nomination, and impeachment for any official who knowingly violates the rule.
Please tell me in writing whether you will introduce, cosponsor or vote for this, and if not, why not.